Votes out of 10 (hentai anime not included):

* Just started

1. One Piece Movie 9 (9.60)
2. Aria the Origination (9.23)
3. Yes! Pretty Cure 5 Go Go (9.00)
=4. Code Geass: Lelouch of the Rebellion R2 (8.96)
=4. Kaiba (8.96)
6. Junjou Romantica (8.88)
=7. Major 4th Season (8.80)
=7. Kara no Kyoukai IV (8.80)
9. Slayers Revolution* (8.76)
10. Blue Dragon: Tenkai no Shichi Ryuu (8.75)
11. Hidamari Sketch x365* (8.62)
12. Spice and Wolf (8.51)
13. Zero no Tsukaima: Princess no Rondo* (8.45)
14. Mnemosyne (8.42)
15. Zoku Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei (8.40)
16. The Daughter of Twenty Faces (8.33)
17. Kurenai (8.31)
=18. Kara no Kyoukai III (8.30)
=18. Soul Eater (8.30)
20. Porfy no Nagai Tabi (8.26)
21. Mai Otome S.ifr (8.24)
22. xxxHOLiC: Kei (8.18)
23. Chi's Sweet Home (8.17)
24. Toshokan Sensou (8.13)
25. True Tears (8.10)
26. Birdy the Mighty Decode* (8.08)
27. Real Drive: Sennou Chousashitsu (7.95)
28. To Heart 2 ad (7.94)
29. Kyou Kara Maou! 3rd Series (7.89)
30. Allison and Lillia (7.88)

Will keep a running tab of this. Though I don't expect much change for a few months....

Oh, and the top ten cellar dwellers:

1. Penguin no Mondai (5.07)
2. Idolmaster - Live For You (5.35)
3. Moegaku 5 (5.45)
4. School Days: Valentine Days (5.47)
5. School Days: Magical Heart Kokoro-chan (5.50)
6. Yu Gi Oh 5D's (5.54)
7. Chocolate Underground* (5.73)
8. Ultraviolet: Code 44* (5.75)
9. Yotsunoha (5.81)
=10. Net Ghost Pipopa (5.83)
=10. Bus Gamer (5.83)

Aria #1, Code Geass R2 9/10, Mnemosyne-Spice And Wolf-Mai Otome rated above 8.....*switch off*

Is this list based on the idea 'it's so bad it's good'?

Then again, it has Kurenai and Alison & Lilia in the 20 so it isn't all bad.

Last Exile wrote:Aria #1, Code Geass R2 9/10, Mnemosyne-Spice And Wolf-Mai Otome rated above 8.....*switch off*

Is this list based on the idea 'it's so bad it's good'?

Then again, it has Kurenai and Alison & Lilia in the 20 so it isn't all bad.

Exactly how many of these show have you actually watched?

I've only been watching Code Geass R2 and it's definitely worthy of being up there.

Last Exile wrote:Mnemosyne-Spice And Wolf rated above 8.....

Is this list based on the idea 'it's so bad it's good'?

Trolling is a bannable offense here isn't it? Because all that post does is make me stabby...

Last Exile wrote:Is this list based on the idea 'it's so bad it's good'?

Would you like me to include the Hentai titles, some of which would make the top 20 look a little different?

1. Aria the Origination (9.04)
2. Code Geass R2 (9.00)
3. Major 4th Season (8.84)
4. xxxHolic Kei (8.81)
5. Kaiba (8.67)
6. Kurenai (8.64)
7. Zoku Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei (8.63)
8. Spice and Wolf (8.54)
Ai no Katachi: Ecchi na Onna no ko wa Kirai... Desuka? (8.43)
=9. Mnemosyne (8.38)
=9. Junjou Romantica (8.38)
11. Porfy no Nagai Tabi (8.30)
12. Mai Otome 0 S.ifr (8.29)
13. Soul Eater (8.28)
14. Toshokan Sensou (8.26)
15. True Tears (8.19)
=16. Real Drive Sennou Chousashitsu (8.18)
=16. The Daughter of Twenty Faces (8.18)
Renketsu Houshiki (8.13)
To Heart 2 ad (8.13)
Shishunki Shoujo (8.12)
18. Chi's Sweet Home (8.08)
Alignment You! You! The Animation (8.05)
Kafun Shoujo Chuuihou! - The Animation (8.05)
19. Kyou Kara Maou 3rd Series (8.03)
20. Allison and Lillia (7.99)

Please do. Give Ryan something to grumble about

Done.

You neglected to mention that something with TAMAKI in it was in the Top 20?!

Hand it over. Now.

Hey, I'm always for sex if it's non-violent and she looks good and likes it.

And since you wanted more rage...another series of xxxHolic, goddamit, curse those Clamp bitches with cancer.

The Nerd Rage BAAWWWWW is strong in this one.

Dammit, I just can't seem to find my RAGE.jpg. You'll just have to imagine it here.

If trolling isn't a bannable offense I propose it should be.

I really wish a group would start subbing Porfy no Nagai Tabi.... They really don't like doing Nippon Animation World Theatre titles.... None of them ever went on with Les Miserables....

Awww..where can i download xxxholic:(...actually i dont like CLAMP.. but xxxholic is the only one i like:"P

Okay little noob, one rule of thumb here is not to ask questions like that. It will only lead to pain and suffering.

nhembeo wrote:Awww..where can i download xxxholic:(...actually i dont like CLAMP.. but xxxholic is the only one i like:"P

We don't give out that kind of information, here. As much as we might like to....

Check your PM's nhembeo.

Oh boy, somebody call White. Bazza is tainting another newcomer.

1. Aria the Origination (9.04)
2. Code Geass R2 (9.00)
3. Major 4th Season (8.84)
4. xxxHolic Kei (8.81)
5. Kaiba (8.67)
6. Kurenai (8.64)
7. Zoku Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei (8.63)
8. Spice and Wolf (8.54)
=9. Mnemosyne (8.38)
=9. Junjou Romantica (8.38)
11. Porfy no Nagai Tabi (8.30)
12. Mai Otome 0 S.ifr (8.29)
13. Soul Eater (8.28)
14. Toshokan Sensou (8.26)
15. True Tears (8.19)
=16. Real Drive Sennou Chousashitsu (8.18)
=16. The Daughter of Twenty Faces (8.18)
18. Chi's Sweet Home (8.08)
19. Kyou Kara Maou 3rd Series (8.03)
20. Allison and Lillia (7.99)

(The bold ones are the ones I recognise and generally find ok if they're the ones I think they are). As for the rest don't think I know them or have heard of them. It's times like these when I feel really un-informed about anime. ^_^; feels like uber newb.

animesuki wrote:1. Aria the Origination (9.04)
2. Code Geass R2 (9.00)
3. Major 4th Season (8.84)
4. xxxHolic Kei (8.81)
5. Kaiba (8.67)
6. Kurenai (8.64)
7. Zoku Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei (8.63)
8. Spice and Wolf (8.54)
=9. Mnemosyne (8.38)
=9. Junjou Romantica (8.38)
11. Porfy no Nagai Tabi (8.30)
12. Mai Otome 0 S.ifr (8.29)
13. Soul Eater (8.28)
14. Toshokan Sensou (8.26)
15. True Tears (8.19)
=16. Real Drive Sennou Chousashitsu (8.18)
=16. The Daughter of Twenty Faces (8.18)
18. Chi's Sweet Home (8.08)
19. Kyou Kara Maou 3rd Series (8.03)
20. Allison and Lillia (7.99)

(The bold ones are the ones I recognise and generally find ok if they're the ones I think they are). As for the rest don't think I know them or have heard of them. It's times like these when I feel really un-informed about anime. ^_^; feels like uber newb.

Is this the part when I hang my head in shame for not only recognising the majority of these titles but have also watched episodes from at least half of the list?
Time to get opinionated and give my impression of the updated list. Comments correspond to list.
1. Pretty
2. Melodramatic awesomeness.
3. Sports anime, therefore haven't seen.
4. On playlist, 'nuff said
5. Animation too avant-garde for my tastes.
6. Seems interesting, but yet to find time to watch.
7. Would be on playlist if decent enough subs could be found.
8. Makes learning about economics enjoyable.
=9. I wish I could put this on the playlist, but it's too risque to risk.
=9. Not even going to watch.
11. Lack of subs make this impossible to give an opinion on.
12. So much better than Mai-Hime, you have trouble with the concept of them being related.
13. Fun to watch. great artwork.
14. Books and guns, I can die happy now.
15. Yet to find time to watch.
=16. Yet to find time to watch.
=16. Good but starts slow, should get faster after episode 7.
18. Cute, but I have no idea why a show aimed at small children is so popular, seriously a clock showing the time of morning when aired is in the corner of the screen.
19. Haven't watched.
20. Starts off slow, good characters but seems a little preachy about war.

Updated.
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=946&p=16781#p16781